Testimony from Beyond: The Greenbrier Ghost Trial
In the winter of 1897, a young bride named Zona Heaster Shue was found dead at the bottom of the stairs in her Greenbrier County, West Virginia home. Her husband, Edward “Trout” Shue, insisted it was natural causes. The doctor called it “an everlasting faint.” The community mourned, accepted, and moved on. At least… until Zona’s mother stepped forward with a story no one could ignore.
Mary Jane Heaster claimed that her daughter’s ghost had returned to her—night after night—revealing the truth: Zona had been murdered, her neck broken in a fit of rage.
It sounds like folklore, a fireside tale meant to spook. But this time, it made its way into the courtroom.
The Death of Zona Heaster Shue
Zona was only 23, newly married to a blacksmith who had drifted into Greenbrier County a year earlier. To outsiders, Edward Shue was charming and hardworking. But Zona’s mother had felt an unease about him from the beginning. On January 23, 1897, Zona’s body was discovered by a neighbor boy.
When the doctor arrived, he found Edward behaving oddly—cradling Zona’s head, dressing her himself, and refusing to let anyone near her neck. A hasty cause of death was signed off as fainting or complications from “female trouble.” Without an autopsy, the case would have ended there.
A Mother’s Intuition—or a Ghost’s Testimony?
Mary Jane Heaster was convinced her daughter had not died naturally. In the weeks following the burial, she prayed for answers. Then, she said, Zona’s spirit appeared to her four nights in a row.
According to Mary Jane, the ghost described exactly how she had been killed: strangled after an argument, her neck “squeezed off at the first joint.” To prove it, the apparition even turned its head all the way around.
Armed with this chilling account, Mary Jane went to the local prosecutor. Whether he believed the ghost story or not, he agreed to reopen the case. Zona’s body was exhumed. The autopsy revealed bruises on her neck, a crushed windpipe, and a dislocated vertebra. Exactly as the ghost had said.
The Trial of Edward Shue
Edward Shue was arrested and brought to trial for murder. The evidence was circumstantial—no eyewitnesses, no direct confession. What the jury did hear, though, was Mary Jane Heaster herself, under oath, calmly repeating the story of her daughter’s ghostly visits.
“It was no dream,” she told the court. “I was as wide awake as I ever was.”
Her composure and consistency stunned the room. The defense had hoped to discredit her, but instead she came across as steadfast and sincere. Combined with Shue’s suspicious behavior and his violent past, the jury returned a guilty verdict. He was sentenced to life in prison, where he died just a few years later.
Folklore Meets the Law
The Greenbrier Ghost case remains the only known U.S. trial where testimony from a ghost was part of the proceedings. Of course, the jury didn’t convict Shue solely because of the apparition. The physical evidence, the autopsy, and his history carried the day. But without Mary Jane’s insistence—whether born of maternal intuition, supernatural experience, or sheer determination—the truth might never have come out.
Today, a state historical marker near Zona’s grave commemorates the case, boldly noting: “Only known case in which testimony from a ghost helped convict a murderer.”
Why the Story Endures
Over a century later, the Greenbrier Ghost is more than just a campfire story. It’s a tale of love, loss, justice, and the blurred line between folklore and fact. Was it really Zona’s spirit that guided her mother? Or was it the instinct of a woman who refused to let her daughter’s death be brushed aside?
Either way, justice was served—and the story of the ghost who took the stand lives on.
Listen to the Full Story
This blog post only scratches the surface. For the complete, eerie tale—including courtroom quotes, autopsy details, and the cultural backdrop of 19th-century Appalachia—listen to our latest episode: “Testimony from Beyond: The Greenbrier Ghost Trial.”
Have thoughts on this story or other cases you’d like to see highlighted? Share them with us in the comments or connect with us on social media. Together, we can ensure that stories like this one are never forgotten.
Don’t forget to follow us on social media, share your thoughts, and let us know what you’d like to hear about in future episodes. If you have any true crime stories of your own, send them our way crimeclueless@gmail.com to be featured on a future episode! And as always, remember: refuse to be clueless, careless, or caught off guard. Not today, murderers.
See you in the next episode of Crime Clueless!
Resources:
Books & Scholarly Sources
Lyle, K. L. (1999). The man who wanted seven wives: The Greenbrier ghost and the famous murder mystery of 1897. McClain Printing Company.
Dietz, D. (2020). The Greenbrier Ghost: And Other Strange Stories. Quarrier Press.
Articles & Historical Accounts
The Greenbrier Independent. (1897, March 9). The Shue murder case: Autopsy reveals broken neck. Greenbrier Independent. (Historic newspaper article covering the autopsy findings.)
Greenbrier Historical Society. (n.d.). The Greenbrier ghost. Retrieved from https://greenbrierhistorical.org
Appalachian History. (Jan. 23, 2018). The Greenbrier Ghost. Retrieved from https://www.appalachianhistory.net
Online Articles & Exhibits
West Virginia Public Broadcasting. (2017, October 31). The Greenbrier Ghost: A mother’s testimony from beyond the grave. Retrieved from https://wvpublic.org
West Virginia Encyclopedia. (n.d.). Greenbrier Ghost. e-WV: The West Virginia Encyclopedia. Retrieved from https://www.wvencyclopedia.org
Appalachian Memories. (n.d.). The Greenbrier ghost of Greenbrier County, WV. Retrieved from https://www.appalachianmemories.org
Atlas Obscura. (n.d.). The Greenbrier Ghost—Lewisburg, West Virginia. Retrieved from https://www.atlasobscura.com
Greenbrier County Convention & Visitors Bureau. (n.d.). The Greenbrier Ghost legend. Retrieved from https://www.greenbrierwv.com
History and Imagination. (n.d.). The Greenbrier Ghost: A true crime tale. Retrieved from https://www.historyandimagination.com
Tourism West Virginia. (n.d.). The legend of the Greenbrier Ghost. Retrieved from https://www.wvtourism.com
Wikipedia contributors. (n.d.). Greenbrier Ghost. In Wikipedia. Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org
American Hauntings Ink. (n.d.). The Greenbrier Ghost. Retrieved from https://www.americanhauntingsink.com
Historical Markers & Memorials
West Virginia Division of Culture and History. (1991). Greenbrier Ghost historical marker. State historic marker text, Greenbrier County, WV.
Whoa, hold onto your hats! This Greenbrier Ghost tale is more than just spooky – its a masterclass in mom power. Seriously, Mary Jane Heaster went full ghost detective, and the court actually let her ghostly testimony in! Talk about tough evidence. Though, I mean, lets be real, the jury probably thought, Okay, weirdo with a ghost, plus creepy guy,Guilty! Its a wild ride from Appalachia folklore to courtroom drama. Love that its getting the recognition it deserves – who knew a ghost helped close a case? Plus, the call to action at the end is pure gold. Refuse to be clueless? Classic! Cant wait for the next episode – just hoping its not *more* ghost cases. Keep these strange stories alive, folks!metal injection molding
Absolutely agree! Supermom status for Mary Jane Heaster absolutely. Thank you for the kind words. We truly appreciate it! Happy Spooky Season!!
This Greenbrier Ghost tale is absolutely *chilling*, though mostly because its such a bizarre courtroom scene! Imagine the judge having to rule on ghost testimony – talk about a legal headache! Mary Jane Heasters composure was *stunning*, probably because she knew her story was more believable than Shues suspicious past. It’s a fascinating glimpse into 19th-century justice where folklore almost overruled fact. Of course, the jury likely went with the physical evidence and Shues bad habits, but come on, a ghost *testified*! Who wouldnt find that compelling? It’s a testament to a mothers determination, whether supernatural or just maternal instinct on overdrive. Definitely more intriguing than explaining Brian Shaffers disappearance. Who knew a ghost could help close a case so effectively? #JusticeServedByApparitionhot wheels
This Greenbrier Ghost tale is a real howler! Who knew a ghosts testimony could make a more compelling case than actual eye-witnesses? Seriously, though, Mary Jane holding her ground in court was a masterclass in maternal intuition – or maybe just really determined ghost-hunting. Either way, its a spooky reminder that in the 19th century, you couldnt just say I think he did it, you had to bring your ghostly detective partner! Justice was served, sure, but imagine the lawyer jokes Shues ghost is still getting in purgatory. A truly eerie episode for the Crime Clueless podcast – cant wait to hear more bizarre cases!deltarune prophecy script
What a truly *chilling* read! Who knew a ghost could help seal a murder conviction? Its the stuff of campfire tales, except with real life imprisonment on the line! Mary Janes composure under oath was certainly *stunning*, though I imagine her internal monologue was something less… *wide awake*. And poor Edward Shue, caught between suspicious behavior and a ghostly testimony – no wonder he went down! It’s a fascinating glimpse into the blurred line between folklore and fact, a perfect example of why we shouldnt be *clueless*. Though I wonder, was that ghost *really* giving evidence, or just a mom with exceptional intuition who refused to let her daughters case be brushed aside? Either way, justice was served, and this story definitely ensures we *refuse to be clueless* about the power of a determined mom!basketball stars unblocked